Welcome to Mama Carolla's
Mama Carolla's, nestled in Indianapolis, is a culinary gem that effortlessly combines elegance with affordability. Located at 1031 E 54th St, this charming restaurant offers an inviting atmosphere, perfect for any occasion—whether it's a romantic date or a family dinner. With highlights like the creamy pesto ravioli and savory garlic cheese bread, every dish showcases fresh ingredients and authentic Italian flavors. Diners rave about the attentive service, with staff going above and beyond to enhance the experience. Mama Carolla's is a must-visit for those seeking a delightful dining experience in the heart of Indy.
-
1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States Hotline: +1 317-259-9412
Welcome to Mama Carolla's, a beloved haven of culinary delight nestled in Indianapolis, at 1031 E 54th St. Since its inception, Mama Carolla's has become synonymous with exceptional dining experiences, making it the go-to spot for everything from intimate date nights to family celebrations.
As you step through the doors, you are greeted by a warm ambiance that blends elegance with comfort. The outdoor patio offers a serene dining experience, perfect for enjoying a crisp evening, while the interior captures a cozy charm. The moment you settle in, the attentive staff begins to weave their magic, ensuring that your every need is met. Reviews from patrons rave about the incredible service, with many singling out specific staff members who go above and beyond to enhance the dining experience.
Mama Carolla's culinary offerings shine through a diverse menu that caters to all palates. Start your meal with the Antipasti Plate, a delightful assortment of prosciutto, aged soppressata, and marinated mozzarella, accompanied by local wholegrain mustard. For something hearty, the Pasta Too Good is a crowd favorite—tender shrimp and chicken mixed with penne and spicy garlic; it’s an explosion of flavor that keeps diners returning for more. If steak is your preference, the Uncle Dino's New York Strip is a must-try, perfectly prepared with cracked black peppercorns and tangy au jus.
The reviews speak volumes. Diners have described their experiences as “the best” they’ve ever had, with dishes like goat cheese shrimp and chicken involtine leaving a lasting impression. Many patrons have found that it’s not just the food but also the camaraderie felt in the restaurant, fostered by an attentive staff. It’s apparent that Mama Carolla's is dedicated to creating not just wonderful dishes, but also unforgettable memories.
Indulge in the flavors and hospitality that make Mama Carolla's a true gem in the heart of Indianapolis. With engaging service, exquisite food, and a welcoming atmosphere, you’ll quickly understand why it’s heralded as one of the best dining spots in the city. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply looking to enjoy a fine meal, let Mama Carolla's be your destination.
The food and cocktails are great. I love coming here for special occasions. The service is great and sitting inside or outside is nice. One of the best restaurants in Indy.
Mama Corolla's is a great choice for dates, hanging with friends, or family dinners. I've tried almost everything there, and I highly recommend the Pasta Too Good with Alfredo sauce. As an appetizer the mussels are always a solid choice too. Its combination of elegance and reasonable pricing makes it a top choice for dining in Indy.
truly the BEST dining experience. my husband and I were traveling from out of town and had this restaurant recommended by several people. both the food and service blew us away. Eric was our server and he was PHENOMENAL. the best service we have had in our entire lives. he gave amazing recommendations and was so attentive all evening. highly recommend the goat cheese shrimp and chicken involtine. they were our favorite dishes of the night. HUGE shoutout to Eric for being so amazing, the food was great but his service absolutely sold us on this restaurant. I will forever recommend this spot to anyone traveling to the area!
My partner and I already love Mama Carolla’s, but last night (April 26), was probably our favorite visit we’ve ever had there. Sherry was our waitress and she was nothing but a joy! Super attentive and timely, but more than that, she went above and beyond to make our experience there absolutely amazing! She walked around the building to get a great photo of us on the patio from the Monon, she made us laugh with her jokes and stories, and every last minute of our dinner was an absolute delight because of her. We almost didn’t want to leave! Next time we are back, we will most definitely be asking to sit in her section!
Hands down the best place for a date night in Indianapolis. Food is absolutely fantastic! We try new dishes every time. Appetizers are incredible and you can feel the effort they pour in everything they make.
This is an old house in Broad Ripple. The place is just magnificent. Delightful service, great food, amazing atmosphere. The price is right. Great date night place! I'd recommend any of the veal dishes. Cooked to perfection. The bread and oil alone is top notch. The parking situation isn't the best, but it's Broad Ripple. Plenty of parking near the breakfast place next door that they also own. If you are still hungry after dinner, the tiramisu is worth the calories. It is made in-house and melts in your mouth.
One of the best places for Italian food in Indy It's always busy and lively and a reservation is highly recommended. Food is delicious. Service is fantastic and the building is a historic home! Appetizers • Bruschetta - heavy on the cheese, crunchy bread and we had our own container of balsamic to pour • provolone with melon - delicious, a bit heavy on the balsamic Entrees • Beef lasagna - Quite good. Serving size was medium large. • Chicken Piccata - The chicken was cooked perfectly, sauce was falvorful. The soup that came with it was Italian wedding soup. It was different than what we had other places. It really seemed like a chicken noodle soup with thinner noodles and just some meatballs and spinach in it.
This is one of the cutest Italian spots in Indianapolis. Their bolognese is absolutely delicious. "The carbonara is really tasty." Calamari comes with sooo much! The creme brulee is perfect!